Monthly Archives: June 2008

AFL to players: Don’t read fan blogs

Before I begin, I need to give a thankyou to Half Back Flanker for the contents of this blog post. If I hadn’t been reading this site then New Media Mogul might have missed this story entirely.

It would appear that the AFL has advised players not to read fan websites, for fear that the vicious player appraisals could lead to depressions, according to the Herald Sun.

You can read the article for yourselves, but it certainly seems that the AFL is doing nothing to build up a relationship with sports fans who are citizen media makers. It would also seem that the AFL is not very well read on emerging forms of media, as the article is quite clearly referring to people who post on forums, considering at one point that it talks about users stealing the identities of players. As pretty much anyone who uses the Internet would know, the interactions and behaviours within a forum are totally different to those found within a blog.

However on the plus side for sports fans, it does show that they have gained some power through social media, with even the always busy AFL coaches being familiar with fan sites like Big Footy and the ‘viscious cyber-bullying’ that is found within them.

It’s obvious though that the AFL doesn’t see the value in sports fans who are citizen media makers, with the article at one point quoting an AFL official, Pippa Grange, who described them as people ‘with not much better to do’.

New Media Mogul always considered that the AFL would be one of the more progressive sporting organisations when it came to dealing with new media issues, so it is disappointing to see that they have about as much interest in social media, as as much understanding of the potential of the medium as the other sporting organisations covered recently. The International Olympic Committee, with its extremely censored Beijing blogs, is now starting to look quite progressive in its use and encouragement of social media.

Citizen media and commercialism

While the idea behind citizen media might be that anyone has the opportunity to create media, the paradox is that to successfully create media requires dedication and time, something which a lot of people who have to hold down a job, raise a family, or do any of the many other things that keep people occupied, don’t have time for.

For example, New Media Mogul is produced because it is aiding in my completion of a Doctor of Philosophy; in any other circumstances I would probably not be able to find the time to blog about new media issues.

But the point is that the most successful citizen media products are put out by people who either have a business model behind their site or are at least in part, paid to blog. Examples of this are Bryanboy from the fashion industry who is hired by organisers of big fashion shows to provide instantaneous reviews of the shows, and FanFooty from the sporting industry; a site that runs a ‘super coach’ game and provides news and scores on the side.

There is nothing wrong with people making money from their citizen media contributions, but the question is, does this need for commercialism dictate the extent to which citizen media can bring about change on the media landscape.

One of the hopes for citizen media is that it will give a voice to groups and views within the mainstream media that are ignored, underrepresented or misrepresented, yet if commercialism comes into the equation, then perhaps these groups will continue to be as unrepresented as they are in the current, very hegemonic, mainstream media.

Commercialism may also eventually dictate the range of content that citizen journalists choose to cover, if like more traditional media, it becomes driven by advertising. This has been witnessed recently in the mainstream media, with ANZ withdrawing advertising to The Footy Show because of its treatment of women and the Nine Network being subsequently forced to respond by ‘resting’ Sam Newman. If advertisers gain the same sort of power over citizen media producers, then perhaps a form of censorship around citizen media content will take hold.

This is why the effect of citizen journalism on the media landscape needs to be carefully examined, because what appears at first glance to be a more democratic and open minded form of the media, may ultimately be an extension of all proprietary mediums, but simply with a lower entry cost.